🎉 WeArisma joins forces with NielsenIQ (NIQ) to, for the first time ever, measure the impact of Creator Marketing on sales.

How tiered gifting can increase your BAI™ score

We’re thrilled to introduce Wearisma’s Brand Advocacy Index™ (BAI™), a proprietary metric that measures the strength of your brand’s community of advocates. In this post, we explore the importance of nurturing relationships with brand advocates, highlight successful strategies, and discuss how tiered gifting can elevate your brand’s advocacy efforts.

Published On: March 29, 2021

Announcing the Launch of Wearisma’s Brand Advocacy Index™ (BAI™)

We’re excited to announce the launch of Wearisma’s Brand Advocacy Index™ (BAI™), our proprietary metric which measures the intensity of your brand’s community of advocates. In our last blog, we outlined the importance of brand advocacy programs and in our webinar, we revealed how a high BAI™ score is crucial to your brand’s survival. Below, we’ll reveal how best to nurture your relationship with your advocates, which brands have seen success with these methods and how tiered gifting can strengthen your advocate community.

Why do you need to nurture a relationship with your brand advocates? 

Not only does research show that effective loyalty programs can generate as much as 20% of a company’s profits, but it also indicates that 84% of consumers are willing to stick with a brand that offers a loyalty program. The more consumers stick with your brand, the higher your BAI™ score. Our research and insights team revealed that brands with a high BAI™ score produce above-average Engagement Rates (ER), suggesting that the more powerful your community of advocates, the more successful your content. Relationships with brand advocates are typically nurtured through loyalty programs to reward advocates for authentically promoting your brand and prevent them from turning to competitors.

Nurturing a relationship with your brand advocates will also encourage a rise in user-generated content (UGC) which is 20% more effective at influencing purchase decisions and 35% more memorable than other types of media. Additionally, Wearisma’s insights revealed that, on average, organic UGC generates 20x the Media Value compared to that of paid content.

Name Surname

Job Title

“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Diam platea at tempor ut ut egestas venenatis. Placerat eros eget commodo ut cursus. Enim libero nibh facilisis est. At phasellus mauris ornare posuere consequat. Quam lacus curabitur consectetur amet libero tortor eu volutpat sit. Venenatis eget aenean in enim.”

Reward your advocates with gifting to see positive results 

Gifting is one of the best ways to nurture a relationship with your advocates. Wearisma’s insights revealed that the ER for #gifted jumped from 2.4% in January 2020 to 3.8% in February 2021. These figures suggest that audiences are becoming increasingly interested in content that shows brands rewarding advocates for their loyalty. Several brands have seen great success with large scale gifting campaigns, such as:

Fabletics

The fitness clothing brand ramped up its gifting in 2020 to great results. Wearisma’s insights reveal that in 2020, #gifted content featuring Fabletics generated an impressive ER of 5%, which is 5 times the average ER for fashion content. Simultaneously, Fabletics saw a 35% increase in BAI™ score year-on-year suggesting that rewarding their loyal advocates contributed to the success of the community’s content.

Nespresso

Using Wearisma’s advanced search feature, our research and insights team identified Nespresso as achieving successful results from gifting. In 2020, #gifted content featuring the Nestlé coffee brand generated a whopping 15% Engagement Rate, 3 times the ER for content featuring coffee.

How tiered gifting takes Brand Advocacy to the next level

Tiered gifting involves giving larger rewards for brand advocates whose content performs the best for your brand. Operating your gifting activities according to a tiered system will ensure that you get the most out of your best advocates and that you are maintaining the strongest connections with your top performers.

4 Steps to Tiered Gifting 

Step 1: Create your tiers

The amount of tiers you have in your gifting system is completely up to you but each gift in your tier should align with the products you are currently promoting. For example, a tier-one gift may be a discount code, a tier-two gift could be sample products while a tier-three gift may include a full-size product. Once you have discovered your advocates they should all typically start on tier-one.

Step 2: Tracking 

After rewarding advocates you must keep a close eye on how they are performing. Besides rewarding your advocates for being loyal to your brand, tiered gifting activities should trigger the psychological principle of reciprocity, i.e. you gift your advocates and they reciprocate the gesture by creating organic content promoting your brand. However, the degree of reciprocity will be higher for some advocates than others which is why the next step is crucial.

Step 3: Monitoring and Reporting

Wearisma’s Monitoring and Reporting tools will allow you to easily see:

  • Who is promoting your brand more frequently
  • Whose content is performing above average in terms of key metrics like Engagements, Engagement Rate and Media Value
  • Who is driving more traffic and sales to your site

Step 4: Evaluating Tier Placement 

After reviewing your report you should be able to easily identify who is performing the best for your brand according to your KPIs. Once you’ve identified these top-performing advocates move them up a tier. For the advocates who have performed below or at average continue to reward them at tier-one as maintaining loyalty with your advocate community will always be important.

Repeating steps 2-4 will ensure that you cultivate a strong community of brand advocates. Using intelligent campaign tools will support you through each step with ease.

Contact a member of our Sales team today to find out more about our solutions. 

Resources

Stay Ahead with the Latest Creator Economy Intelligence

Access timely cultural trends, strategic creator guidance, and industry best practices.

Entertainment Marketing: Leveraging Pop Culture For Brand Success: Key Panel Takeaways

Discover the most groundbreaking entertainment marketing insights from our eye-opening panel discussion at ‘The State of Influence 2025 and future-proof your brand for tomorrow’s creator economy.

New York Fashion Week FW26

Luxury Global Analysis.

New York Fashion Week FW26 generated $275M in total Media Value, up +73% YoY, but leadership was highly concentrated and strategically differentiated.

Regional power shifts and platform momentum reshaped the competitive landscape.

2026 Beauty Influencer Marketing Trends

Coty: Client Success Story

Stay Ahead with WeArisma Intelligence

Join our community and get cultural insights, creator strategy guides, and real-world best practices.

  • See who’s shaping culture, and how.
 
  • Access practical guides and strategy tools.
 
  • Understand how top brands are growing ROI and productivity.
 
  • Read expert takes on what’s next.

Join the Community